Why one number isn't enough
A single projection tells you what happens if growth is exactly what you assumed, every single year, for the next thirty-plus years. It won't be. Markets have good decades and bad ones, and the order matters as much as the average — a couple of weak years early in drawdown can do more damage than several weak years later on, because you're selling down a smaller pot to fund the same withdrawal.
That's why this calculator runs three scenarios side by side, using Penli's standard low, mid and high growth assumptions, rather than one single-line forecast. Seeing where the lines diverge is more useful than any one of them on its own.
A worked example
Take a £300,000 pot at age 65, £23,000 a year withdrawn (rising with inflation each year so it buys the same in real terms), the full new State Pension of about £12,535 a year arriving from age 67, a 0.75% charge, and 2.5% inflation.
Under low growth (3% a year), the pot runs out at 90. Under mid growth (5% a year), it stretches to 99 — nine extra years from the same withdrawal, purely down to the growth assumption. Under high growth (7% a year), it never runs out inside the 100-year age this calculator models to. Three assumptions, three very different retirements, from the same starting numbers.
Notice, too, how much the State Pension is doing here. Once it lands at 67, it covers a chunk of that £23,000 need every year, and the pot only has to fund the rest. Delaying withdrawals until State Pension age, or leaning on other income first, is one of the biggest levers in how long a pot lasts — bigger, in many cases, than shaving a fraction off the withdrawal rate.
What the result actually means
"Runs out" here means the pot reaches zero under a constant, inflation-linked withdrawal that never adjusts down. Nobody actually retires like that. In practice, most people spend more flexibly than a spreadsheet — cutting back a little in years the pot has fallen, and easing off some withdrawals is usually enough to avoid running out altogether. Treat the age shown as a warning signal for a fixed spending pattern, not a countdown to an actual date.
If the low-growth scenario runs out well before the mid or high scenario, that's the gap worth paying attention to — it's telling you how sensitive your plan is to a run of poor returns, which matters more than the average of the three.
Common mistakes people make
The most common is ignoring inflation on the withdrawal itself. £23,000 today needs to become roughly £23,575 next year and more the year after just to buy the same amount — a pot that looks fine against a flat £23,000 a year can run out years earlier once that's built in, which is exactly why this calculator escalates the withdrawal automatically rather than leaving it flat.
The second is forgetting charges. A 0.75% annual charge doesn't sound like much next to a 5% growth assumption, but it's compounding against you every single year of drawdown, not just accumulation — it comes straight off the net growth rate used to project the pot forward here.
The third is leaving other income out of the sums, or assuming State Pension age is fixed at 66 forever. It's already legislated to rise to 67 by 2028, and a future government review could move it further. Check your own date on GOV.UK's State Pension forecast rather than assuming.
Scottish taxpayers
This calculator doesn't apply income tax to the withdrawals shown — it's modelling how long the pot itself lasts, not what you'd net after tax on each withdrawal. If you want the tax due on a specific withdrawal, including the different Scottish income tax bands, use the pension tax-free lump sum calculator, which handles that side of things directly.
What this doesn't cover
It doesn't model annuities, which trade some or all of a pot for a guaranteed income that can't run out — see the annuity vs drawdown calculator for a side-by-side comparison of the two approaches. It also assumes one constant growth rate per scenario rather than the up-and-down sequence markets actually produce, and it doesn't account for any tax due on the withdrawals themselves.